Ethiopia: Loan from United Nations Fund Allows Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) to Scale Up Fertilizers for Farmers in TigrayRead more How Choosing the Right Printer Helps Small Businesses and Content Creators to Save Time, Maximise Productivity and Achieve GrowthRead more The United States Contributes USD $223 Million to Help World Food Programme (WFP) Save Lives and Stave Off Severe Hunger in South SudanRead more Eritrea: World Breastfeeding WeekRead more Eritrean community festival in Scandinavian countriesRead more IOM: Uptick in Migrants Heading Home as World Rebounds from COVID-19Read more Network International & Infobip to offer WhatsApp for Business Banking Services to Financial Institution Clients across AfricaRead more Ambassador Jacobson Visits Gondar in the Amhara Region to Show Continued U.S. Support for the Humanitarian and Development Needs of EthiopiansRead more Voluntary Repatriation of Refugees from Angola to DR Congo ResumesRead more Senegal and Mauritania Are Rich in Resources, Poor in Infrastructure, Now Is the Time to Change That Read more

Seeking civility in groups as views clash on Facebook

Print Friendly and PDF

Oct 05, 2020 - 07:39 AM

SAN FRANCISCO — As division roils the country ahead of the US presidential election, Justine Lee is out to “Make America Dinner Again” and foster understanding in the process.

The creator of the private Facebook group by that name faces the challenge of keeping conversation civil at a social network criticized as a cauldron of toxicity.

MADA was started when Lee, who lives in New York’s Bronx borough, and a friend were stunned by the outcome of the 2016 presidential election and began holding dinner parties to bring together people with opposing political viewpoints.

The dinners caught on. After the coronavirus pandemic struck and prevented face-to-face gatherings, MADA went virtual with a Facebook group.

The group has not shied away from hot-button discussion topics including race, police brutality and abortion.

While Facebook relies on automated systems and user reports to filter out unacceptable vitriol, groups have human moderators who can reject posts or turn off comments if discussions go off the rails.

Rather than Facebook or its chief Mark Zuckerberg deciding what is acceptable, groups outline their own standards.

“It is clear that these are the norms that we’ve agreed to as a group, and if you don’t agree with them or you can’t adhere to them, you’re out,” Lee said.

“I feel like the rest of the internet is just too big to be like that.”

MADA has around 850 members and a dozen moderators – six of them politically left-leaning and six right-leaning.

The future is private 

Facebook — which with more than 2.7 billion monthly users is the leading social network — has been trying to shake off its image as a dangerously sprawling platform by emphasizing private communications and small groups.

“As the world gets bigger and more connected, we need that sense of intimacy more than ever,” Zuckerberg said when announcing a tactical shift last year.

“That’s why I believe the future is private.”

Facebook doesn’t place ads in groups, but data collected in public groups is used to recommend content and target ads elsewhere on the platform.

MADA hosted a virtual watch party this week for the first US presidential debate between Donald Trump and Joe Biden. Lee helped moderate.

“When things got a little bit tense, we invited people to use ‘gifts’ and emojis to lighten the mood a bit and express what they were feeling rather than their words,” Lee said.

Even with flashpoint topics, group conversations often benefit from members having bonded over children, pets, hobbies and other shared interests or adversities, according to Lee.

Contagious kindness 

After seeing the rampant anxiety caused by Covid-19, Australian doctor Catherine Barrett launched The Kindness Pandemic.

The group, which focuses particularly on acts of kindness between generations, has grown to more than 500,000 members.

“People join our group to create a better world,” said Barrett, with a drawing of a heart decorating a refrigerator behind her during a video call.

“That sounds lofty, but it’s really where it comes from. Our group has a very low tolerance for unkindness.”

Facebook just added software tools for group administrators, such as automatically flagging specified words or barring members from posting until they have been in a group for awhile.

Posts shared to spark group discussions typically must be pre-approved by moderators.

“I don’t enjoy Facebook because I think people have been really negative,” Barrett said of the broader social network.

“I think people in our group appreciate the fact it is not toxic.”

Risk or reward? 

Facebook and others have grappled with how to purge vile content from online platforms without stifling free expression.

Facebook this week said it is raising the profile of member groups, hoping people with different views will find common ground there.

“Groups are allowing people to engage with very different perspectives and backgrounds,” Fidji Simo, head of Facebook App, told AFP.

“It’s something we can use now more than ever.”

Facebook this month is marking the 10th anniversary of groups, which were growing in popularity even before the pandemic made online socializing a cultural norm.

They are now used by more than 1.8 billion people monthly.

Groups have surged for several reasons, including support for the Black community as the United States faces a reckoning on race and police brutality.

According to Simo, groups devoted to quirky pandemic trends and light-hearted content have also grown during the health crisis.

But Jennifer Grygiel, an assistant professor of communications at Syracuse University, said she worries that promoting groups might further drown out the free press ahead of a crucial election.

“The timing is so off,” Grygiel said. “This is risky.”

  • bio
  • twitter
  • facebook
  • latest posts

ZONNTECH.COM uses both Facebook and Disqus comment systems to make it easier for you to contribute. We encourage all readers to share their views on our articles and blog posts. All comments should be relevant to the topic. By posting, you agree to our Privacy Policy. We are committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion, so we ask you to avoid personal attacks, name-calling, foul language or other inappropriate behavior. Please keep your comments relevant and respectful. By leaving the ‘Post to Facebook’ box selected – when using Facebook comment system – your comment will be published to your Facebook profile in addition to the space below. If you encounter a comment that is abusive, click the “X” in the upper right corner of the Facebook comment box to report spam or abuse. You can also email us.